
I’ve pored over The Lucky Guide to Mastering Any Style, a book that outlines some fundamental feminine styles – bombshell, American classic, Bohemian, rock & roll – and suggests essential pieces to procure if you’d like to try these looks out for yourself. Although I disagreed with many of their requisite item suggestions (Are bright yellow zippered sandals ESSENTIAL to nailing the “mod” look? I think not!), I was fascinated by how tidily they distilled each style into a handful of staples. Making these iconic styles work suddenly seemed so simple, laid out there in neatly organized rows of clothing, shoes, and accessories.
But in reality, defining your personal style is no mean feat. You can wear what the mags tell you to wear, but very little of your true self is likely to shine through all those of-the-moment pieces. You can chose a single, classic style like the ones described in Lucky’s guide, but you’ll probably feel trapped by the constraints of an aesthetic that is so rigidly defined. You can do what most of us do and wear a well-meaning but unwieldy hodgepodge of pieces that you’ve accumulated over several years’ shopping time … but, like most of us, you’ll end up looking unrefined, undefined, and uncertain.
So what’s a girl to do?
Well, a girl can start with one of the exercises suggested below. These are merely jumping off points, since personal style refinement is a complex, slow-moving, and deeply personal process. No two women will take the same route to signature-look-creation, and their routes may encompass years of false starts, experiments, and total about-faces. But if you’re drowning in a sea of bland, undefined clothes and accessories, desperate for a lighthouse that will guide you toward the shores of Styletown, consider giving one of these babies a whirl:
1. Identify a celebrity style icon
Celebrities, obviously, are going to err on the side of trendy. But many of them have well-paid stylists whose sole responsibility is to make them look tee-totally gorgeous before they leave the compound for their morning latte. So, you know, celebs generally look pretty damn good and can teach us a thing or two about impeccable style. Spend some time poring over fashion and gossip mags and websites, and see who strikes your fancy. Are you drawn to Katie Holmes’ classic chic? Sharon Stone’s unapologetic sexiness? Rachel Bilson’s playful gamine? SJP’s arty experimentation? Tear out some images and make an inspiration collage. Look in your closet and identify pieces you already own that your celebrity soulmate would wear. Examine the pieces that don’t fit in. If your newly elected style icon was FORCED to wear these items, how would she accessorize and style them to make them work? What key items are missing from your wardrobe that will make you more aligned with your celeb of choice?
2. Indentify a non-celebrity style icon
Now be careful with this one, girls, as it must stay firmly in the realm of imitation-as-flattery and never veer off into Single White Female territory. Most of us know at least one woman who looks perfectly put together every day. No matter if she’s running out to buy tampons and ice cream, headed to a business meeting, or jetting off to a posh cocktail party, she always looks chic, natural, and perfectly herself. Never a good idea to become a straight-up mimic, but – as you would with a celeb icon – poke your head into your closet and pick pieces you could imagine this woman wearing.
How would she accessorize and style the items that don’t fit her look? What about her style would you change to make it your own? If you’re not comfortable emulating a woman in your own social circle, cruise around the wardrobe_remix group on Flickr. There are more than 10,000 people posting daily outfit images to this group, so you’re bound to find someone in there whose style speaks to you. Once you’ve identified a woman with covetable style, click on her username to view her personal photostream. Then follow the closet-refining steps outlined above.
3. Make a list for today, and one for tomorrow
Not interested in drawing inspiration from anyone other than yourself? Not a problem. Grab a cup of coffee, a notepad, and a pen. Start by listing words that describe your current style. Are you classic, messy, conservative, eclectic, punky, or casual? List the main colors in your closet. Are you all black, white, and gray? Obsessed with autumnal tones like olive, orange, brown, and oatmeal? Does your pastel-packed closet look like an enormous Easter egg? Describe the cut of your clothes: Boxy, fitted, loose, long, cropped. Finally, get some really outrageous descriptors of your style working: Gypsy, water, toucan, architect, harlot, garden, stargazer. NOW! Quickly – without thinking too hard – jot down anything about your current style that you find dissatisfying.
Finally, make a list of adjectives and phrases that you WANT to describe your personal style. Do you want to be more colorful, textural, structured, ladylike, edgy, or bold? Do you want to wear skirts all the time, or employ more hoisery and jewelry, or be less girly? What items do you have now that fit into your ideal style? If you could only buy three new items to help get you moving toward this style, what would they be?
4. Pick your five faves
Go to your closet and select your five absolute favorite, pedestal-worthy, save-them-from-a-house-fire items. Now, I’m not talking about the pieces that you wear the most often, because those are likely to be basics. I’m talking about the items that called to you – nay, SCREAMED at you – from the shop window, the items that you gratefully paid full price for, the items that draw tons of compliments but only get worn a few times a year. Why do you love them? Take the first item of the five, and build three outfits around it using only clothes and accessories you already own. Do this with numbers two, three, four, and five. Think about the look you’re defining by putting these items at the center of your stylistic universe. How would you describe it? Can you maintain it? Can you style some of your more staid pieces – with accessories, shoes, or embellishments – so that they align with this new direction?
Often, defining your personal style is more about elimination than procurement: You are very likely to require a purge, but less likely to require a shopping trip. Start with what you’ve already got that fits into your desired aesthetic, and work on HOW to wear it. Keep items that show even a glimmer of potential, but jettison items you’re 100% sure won’t work with your chosen stylistic direction. Create a wishlist of clothing, shoes, and accessories that will enrich your new look … but try not to shop until you’ve lived inside it for at least a month. You might change your mind, or tweak your ideas. No need to rush the process, as it will become a lifelong one.
As you can see from the photos at the top of this post, MY personal style is extremely eclectic. I explore it daily right here, yet was unable to identify my signature look in any of the styles showcased in The Lucky Guide to Mastering Any Style. Nevertheless, I am very deliberate in my selection of new wardrobe items: They must show off my waist and mask my hips, they must have a touch of yesteryear, they must be chunky and bold, they must be extremely versatile, they must either be utterly classic or utterly fascinating. I think of my style as arty-eclectic with a broad streak of retro influence. And although that may sound vague as fog to you, it makes perfect sense to me because I’ve spent years defining and refining it. I can look at a piece in a store and know instantly if it will work with my look, or be jarring and unwelcome.
Now. Since you are not done evolving, your style is not done evolving. There’s no reason to pick a direction today and force yourself to move in that direction ad infinitum. But exploring your personal style is a fantastic way to explore your inner landscape. The choices we make about physical presentation define first impressions, broadcast information about our tastes, and give observers a tiny glimpse into who we really are. Dedicating some time and energy to identifying the boundaries of your look is an investment in self-knowledge and self-confidence that is guaranteed to pay off.
Reposted from Look and Feel.







![Validate my RSS feed [Valid RSS]](wp-content/themes/thesis_18/custom/images/valid-rss-rogers.png)
{ 42 comments… read them below or add one }
Lots of great pieces and absolutely interchangeable you can built 10 more outfits off of what you’ve already shown.
You’re right I do have both celebrity and real people I admire and try to copy. I really like your #4!!!! sound advice!
Super smart way to think about personal style!!! Now I’ve got all of these ideal flowing…
Awesome ; – )
Sal: you know what I like about you, in addition to your honesty about yourself, and your great posts about style? I like that you spelled “pored over” correctly, instead of “poured over.” I’m a spelling geek. Thanks!
Sallymandy: Hahaha, thanks, doll! I WAS a copy editor in a past life … albeit a completely crappy one.
When I culled my closet, I also found it helpful to look at what I owned that I never, ever wore. The reason I didn’t wear it did not really matter…it had to go.
I think I’ve definitely defined my style in the past year, and downsizing my closet (without mercy) was the most important step.
this is a great post… i’ve been thinking about your “what do you want to look like” post since i read it and i feel like i am ready to take this next step, but until now i didn’t really know what that was.
thank you!
Now that I’ve gotten over my excitement about your spelling, I can move on to this thought provoking post!
My favorite idea here is the one about looking at what we already have. I need to pay really close attention to myself or I completely derail into someone else’s aesthetic. Therefore, the first two ideas are kind of dangerous for me. In a way, I interpret what you said in this idea as “look to myself as a style icon. Figure out why I bought the stuff I love, and build on it.”
I’ve borrowed an idea I read many years ago about defining an interior decorating style: trust that if we buy things we love, they’ll hang together into a personal aesthetic of some sort. I love this applied to clothing. The key is knowing myself and what I really love.
Have a great week!
p.s. copy editing…argh. I considered it once, too.
Since I have been working on my style lately this post is GREAT.
Thanks
You do defy the styles in that Lucky guide. I think I might too!
BTW, suggestion 4 is genius. What a way to a) increase creativity while b) getting more use out of something you love and c) saving money (cuz you’ll need less when you do more with what you have) and d) getting organized. So smart, Sal.
Why do I hate the idea of defining my style so much?
You are brilliant and I am printing this post and doing this exercise. Jut reading it I have decided to wear that polkadot Dana Buchman skirt that I begged, borrowed and pleaded with my inner scrooge to get. I haven’t worn it in over a year. I am taking it out this week.
WendyB: It can be super confining to “define your style,” especially for someone as stylistically adventurous as you! I love categories and shorthand, so style definition appeals to me … but it ain’t for everyone.
I really enjoyed this post! I’ve always had a pretty definite sense of self-style (even my misguided days of trying to dress “trendy”, I still raided the local vintage shops and worked those pieces in!), but lately it’s gotten a bit muddled with being at-home all day. So, this was just the kick in the pants I needed to refocuse get my style back on!
lol. Thanks again for an insightful, humorous and well-written post, Sal!
As my style has been developing, I’ve been learning what does and doesn’t work for me. The styles I’m most drawn in the Lucky Guide to are European chic, Mod and American classic, but what I wear often doesn’t fit neatly into those categories. I look at them more for inspiration than for concrete examples of what I should be wearing.
I love your tips! So true…I have definitely found that wardrobe remix is a godsend for outfit ideas. On my most unmotivated mornings I can always find something interesting to do from the great pictures there!
Also, that burst-o-color outfit on the far right is more than adorable! I love everything about it!
This is such a great and informative post. I just yesterday cleared out my closet for Spring and found that I really lack a strong wardrobe. I have a lot of fun and interesting pieces but lack a real cohesiveness. This was extremely helpful and will have to let you know how spring shopping and cleaning continue to go.
xx,
Sam @PrettyLovely
This is a great post and I am going to have to try out some of your suggestions. I am personally going through this very process. I just turned 30 and realized that I haven’t bought new clothes since I was 20. My style is not what it was 10 years ago which explains why I wear the same 5 shirts and 3 pairs of jeans everyday. I am weeding through my wardrobe to find my 5 faves. So far I only have one absolute.
Love your boots so much!
Hi there-I would say that I’m influenced a lot by other bloggers styles, magazines and trends. Its easy to buy into a trend through thrifting (as you mentioned in a previous post!)and if you get fed up, its not been a financial disaster. I like to try different styles and eras, if I like an item and its wearable, I’ll go for it!!
I LOVE this post. I’ve been thinking about my personal style a lot lately and trying to figure out a way to document this process of getting my mind wrapped around it. I admire the way you can articulate what is uniquely you.
I love the point about not needing a new shopping trip.. I think sometimes my first reaction is to go on a shopping trip but what I always miss is that my personal style is probably captured in many of the pieces that I probably already own.
What’s funny is that I picked up that book in the bookstore because I was drawn to how pretty it is and I’m a sucker for neat layout but after skimming it… I felt like it didn’t have much substance. You articulated the issues way better than I could’ve so thumbs up.
Thanks for the inspiration I needed to keep evolving and post to a blog!…
~Ella
What a handy guide!
Very good advice.
I personally think style has to start with knowing what colours and cuts/silhouettes look good on you. Lifestyle is also an important factor! (Flat shoes for me, baby!) From this foundation you can then add in elements that appeal – whether retro, sparkly, deconstructed, bright vs muted colour etc. I’m just imagining myself teaching school in full-on ‘bombshell’ style . . . obviously that wouldn’t work!
What an inspiring post, Sal. Lately I’ve been getting the feeling that the items in my closet are encompassing a broader and broader spread of styles. Great for selection, but not so great if you don’t want to give the impression that you’re sartorially schizophrenic. I love the idea of working with a few faves as a way to find out what your wardrobe items have in common. I desperately need to cull, and this will be a great way to get started.
That’s a fascinating post. Most interestingly, although I wouldn’t choose those words, that description you gave your style matches that sequence of photos perfectly.
saving these great tips!!
Great post! I love fashion, but sometimes I still feel like I don’t have it all together, kind of like a style schizophrenic. Mostly my style is JCrew, occasionally with a bit of bohemian Anthropologie. But I quite often I get tired of those looks and get a hankering to dress more Emmanuel Alt/rock glam. Problem is, as a SAHM, the latter doesn’t really fit my lifestyle!
What’s a girl to do?! Should I try to be more consistent and dress more to my (boring) lifestyle?
Sal, this post is worth nearly the cost of my closet!!! Thanks for it!
mm excellent, usable tips!
I’m really excited to sit down with a cup of coffee and my closet and try to hone. I’ve been thinking a lot about how I want to present myself as I transition from a college student with no life aside from work to a young teacher with social events to attend. I love the idea of a celebrity and a real life muse.
Thanks for all the encouraging words
This is seriously great Sal! I’m always trying to pin down my style since I tend to be all over the place, but this makes so much sense! THANK YOU!
Cheryl: No need to boring yourself up, lady! If the rocker chick looks appeals, but doesn’t fit your lifestyle, try working a few accessories from that genre into daily wear. A studded belt here, a big floaty black scarf there … throw those pieces into the mix with your preppy basics and see what happens.
And if you’re feeling scattered about your style, try to draw from at least two groups whenever you dress: A prep piece with a rocker, an Anthro/boho with a prep, etc. The pieces can be small touches, but make sure you’re implementing at least two at a time. You’ll eventually hone your OWN eclectic blend that is perfectly you.
I love this post
Number 4 is definitely something I always try to do. I constantly think of new ways to wear what I have, and how I can use my favourite pieces to get more wear out of them. I also try to make sure that I know that new pieces will fit with my looks before spending the cash. And with regards to a style icon, I’m not sure that I really have one. There are celebs I respect, and more so celebs whose stylists I respect. But Johnny Depp has to top my list, he never uses stylists, and has a clear and exciting style of his own.
Sal, thanks for your tips. I will definitely look over my wardrobe and do some culling and try to work in your suggestions over the next few weeks. Love your style advice! I am due for a closet makeover as I’m reluctant to add any new pieces while I’m feeling somewhat schizoid about my ever-evolving style.
Oh Sal, I just loved this post I feel so related with somethings you say.
I’m always trying to find my style, to name it, but in my own way, with my imagination, always trying to evolve.
Do I sucssed?? I don’t know. Really don’t. that’s my problem, it seems I can’t see myself…
xoxo
I wish I could define my style. Y’know, about fifteen years ago, I tried to redefine myself as Sophisticated Professional, mostly with the inspiration of the Chic Simple books. It made it easy to get dressed, but it did get SO BORING!
The trouble with the styles I admire, really, is that I’m not built for them. My ideal, to which I keep returning, is a kind of Japanese minimalism crossed with boho, but the honest truth is that a round, hourglass-shaped figure is never going to look cool and architectural in that kind of clothing, only either blocky or messy.
I mean, Tilda Swinton is my celebrity ideal, and this woman (http://lookbook.nu/user/444-Biz-C) makes my wardrobe jealous, but most of that stuff is simply Not Good on me.
On the other hand, I am abandoning the brief flirtation with colour and print which I tried out in the last two years. Though admittedly occasionally cute, it’s never felt quite right.
I really love your idea of five favorites and can’t wait to try it. I’ve always had just a few items of clothes, for a variety of reasons, but now it’s because I really think about what I like to wear. I still make shopping mistakes, but not too often. I like to have a few things to mix up differently and then wear them out! Then I can buy new things!
I think I love a bombshell, but that’s hard to pull off in every situation. But deep down, I think that’s who I am. So I guess I try to incorporate touches of that style a little bit everyday.
Great piece!
I LOVED the post, and the suggestions are great! I have a question for you – it might seem a little strange but maybe you could help me! I've been trying to find a celebrity whose clothes' size would be similar to mine. I don't really consider myself "plus-size" but I feel like I need to find someone who is about size 10 so I can see what kind of clothes they wear. Maybe you have someone in mind?
Thank you for the link!America is georgeous!!
Thank you SO much for posting this! I found your page throug cupcakesandcashmere, and I just love your blog! Really practical, helpful posts
What creative ways to think about our evolutions! I’ve heard of emulating well dressed friends or celebrities but your extra step of imagining how, if forced, they’d work ones less glamourous pieces is brilliant. I really love #4. Great exercises, great imagination, generous and gentle soul – thank you so much!